Mansfield ISD votes to move to single-member districts

November 19, 2026
Share this article
Mansfield ISD board members voted 4-3 to switch to single-member districts to elect trustees at Tuesday's meeting.

By Amanda Rogers

Mansfield Record

The Mansfield ISD school board narrowly approved a new way to elect board trustees at a crowded and contentious meeting Tuesday night at the Dr. Jim Vaszauskas Center for Performing Arts.

The board voted 4-3 to approve single-member districts to represent different areas of the 94-square-mile school district. Five trustees will represent five different areas, while two trustees will be elected at-large by the entire district. School board president Jandel Crutchfield, board vice president Ana-Alicia Horn, board secretary Jason Thomas and Michele Gooch voted in favor of single-member districts, while Benita Reed, Michelle Newsom and Jesse Cannon II voted against.

The issue drew a crowd of more than 150 to the board meeting and public hearing with 32 addressing their concerns and support for the decision in public comments.

A map dividing the district into sections with trustees names attached was posted with the board agenda, along with the year each trustee position would be elected. On Tuesday morning, the Mansfield ISD website added a new clause, indicating that instead of requiring at least 51 percent of the vote to win an election that the candidate getting the most votes will take the position, eliminating any need for runoffs if three or more candidates run for a seat.

Battle lines were quickly drawn with champions for the measure, people vehemently against it and many urging the district to let the public vote on the issue. Several former school board members and one former Mansfield City Council member spoke, all against single-member districts.

“If trustees believe in the change, put it to the voters,” said former board member Karen Marcucci. “Listen to the voters. Take your time. If it’s that good, it can wait.”

Former board member Desiree Thomas agreed, saying the board should be more focused on the $20 million budget deficit the district is facing this year. The board had heard earlier in the meeting from the Financial Future Committee, which has been exploring ways to make up the shortfall, including closing schools, reconfiguring grade levels in schools and eliminating free transportation,

“Why is your focus on this right now?” Thomas asked. “Single-member districts should be on the bottom of your priority list.”

Several school board members pointed to a district survey taken this summer that said some members of the community do not feel represented or heard in the district. Some speakers supported that, saying other members of the community don’t feel comfortable coming forward to speak.

“Our school board should be reflective of our federal representation and how my city council is represented in Arlington,” said Courtney Waters. “It is not surprising that a district that had to be forced to integrate is against equal representation.”

“Arlington and Grand Prairie are forgotten,” said Omar Jimenez.

Cannon made a motion to remove the single-member district item from the agenda, and Newsom seconded. The motion was defeated 4-3, which Newsom, Reed and Cannon voted for and Crutchfield, Horn, Thomas and Gooch voting against it. Horn made a motion to adopt single-member districts, and Gooch seconded it.

All seven board members took turns explaining how they would be voting on single-member districts before the vote was taken. Board members could not even agree on how much the cost to switch to single-member districts would be with some claiming $35,000 for demographers to draw the map and others saying up to $100,000.

“We need to address ‘What is the problem?’” Reed said. “We have to identify the problem. If we don’t, we are moving blindly.”

Newsom called out the process.

“These decisions have taken place without all the board members being fully informed,” she said. “In the past 12 years, I have felt like my vote matters. In the past three months, I have felt like my vote doesn’t matter.”

Cannon pointed to the results of the survey, saying he believes the results reflect an earlier school board, not the current one.

“I feel in many ways we’ve lost the community’s trust,” he said.

Thomas responded that many families in the district don’t feel represented and single-member districts would fix that.

“Under the proposed plan, every voter gets three trustees,” he said.

Horn said that was why she was for the plan, pointing out that at-large votes work for small districts, but not when a district gets as large as Mansfield.

“When a system works for you, it doesn’t look broken,” she said.

Crutchfield pointed at Mansfield’s history and problems integrating in 1956.

“History is watching us,” she said. “In a diverse district like ours, people are not always going to agree.

“In the July 26, 1955, school board minutes, T.M. Moody asked the school board to end segregation,” she said. “The school board voted unanimously to kick the can down the road. This vote is a compromise with five single-member and two at-large trustees.”

TRENDING ARTICLES
Get the word out!

Mansfield, Texas, is a booming city, nestled between Fort Worth and Dallas, but with a personality all its own. The city’s 76,247 citizens enjoy an award-winning school district, vibrant economy, historic downtown, prize-winning park system and community focus spread across 37 square miles. The Mansfield Record is dedicated to reporting city and school news, community happenings, police and fire news, business, food and restaurants, parks and recreation, library, historical archives and special events. The city’s only online newspaper launched in September 2020 and will offer introductory advertising rates for the first three months at three different rates.

Advertise with us!